Comparison of open loop and closed loop stepping systems
Let us first explore the comparison of torque and efficiency in a high performance closed loop stepper system with a conventional open loop stepper system.
The closed-loop stepping system is superior to the open-loop system. As shown in the laboratory test results, the acceleration (torque), efficiency (power consumption), position error (accuracy), heat generation and noise level of the two systems are compared. Only consider the relationship between torque and acceleration. The torque-speed curve shows that the peak and continuous torque range of the closed-loop stepper system is significantly better than the available torque range of the open-loop stepper system. Normally, torque in the real world translates into acceleration - so a motor with more torque can accelerate a given load faster.
In order to test this difference in torque performance in the laboratory, the same size of open-loop and closed-loop stepper motor systems achieve the same inertia load. The programming command two systems execute the same mobile profile, except that the acceleration rate and maximum speed increase slowly in each system until they generate a positioning error.
Here we have a comparison of the moving profiles between the open loop and the closed loop system. This is a comparison between the StepSERVO closed loop system and the system from the open loop system. The closed loop system (due to its higher torque generating capability) achieves a maximum acceleration rate of 2,000 rpm / 2 and a maximum speed of 20 rev / sec (1,200 rpm) as shown here.
Assume that the maximum acceleration of the open loop system is 1,000 rev / sec 2 and the maximum speed is 10 rev / sec (600 rev / min). The maximum rotational speed of 10 rpm is related to the position at which the flat portion of the torque-speed curve ends. The closed loop system (due to its higher torque generating capability) achieves a maximum acceleration rate of 2,000 rpm / 2 and a maximum speed of 20 rev / sec (1,200 rpm). This is twice the performance of the open loop system and reduces the travel time by nearly half - from 110 milliseconds to 60 milliseconds.

For applications that require high response (such as indexing, edge-oriented positioning, and pick and place systems), closed-loop systems offer significant performance advantages.
If you want to buy a vacuum cleaner motor, please pay attention to Vacuum Cleaner Ac Motor.





